|
Court Rejects Vanunu Petition Against Security Restrictions
Haaretz
July
26, 2004
By Yoav Stern, Haaretz Correspondent, and Itim
The High Court of Justice rejected Monday a petition filed by nuclear
whistleblower Mordechai Vanunu against the restrictions imposed on
him by the security services following his release from prison in
April.
Vanunu was released from prison in April after serving an 18-year
term for revealing secrets about Israel's nuclear program to the
London Sunday Times.
After the ruling was handed down, Vanunu said the whole world can now
see how two-faced the state of Israel is.
"We are saying always that Israel is not a real democracy and today
we are seeing it inside the High Court," Vanunu told reporters. "We
will find a way to continue to survive and demand the rights to live
as best we can."
Vanunu has said he wants to live abroad and insists he has no more
state secrets to reveal.
"My country is not Israel. My country is outside of Israel. Israel
didn't respect me for 18 years. For 18 years, Israel condemned me as
a traitor, as a spy. I don't like Israel, I don't want to live in
Israel. I want to be free and to leave Israel," Vanunu said.
Vanunu's attorney, Dan Yakir, said he regretted the High Court
ruling, and that the limitation imposed on his client violated basic
human rights.
Vanunu said he is considering further legal action. He could request
the three-judge Supreme Court panel be expanded to hear the case
again, however such appeals are often rejected.
Vanunu - who insists on speaking English - said he would continue to
live in St. George's Cathedral, a church not far from Jerusalem's Old
City, explaining that he feels more comfortable among Palestinians
and foreigners.
Vanunu, who is now a prominent
figure in the international anti-nuclear weapons movement, also criticized
a recent visit to
Israel by Mohamed ElBaradei, the head of the United Nations nuclear
watchdog. "
I am very disappointed by Mr. Baradei because I expected him to go
and inspect the Dimona reactor," Vanunu said. "The job of Mr. Baradei
is to go and see if what I said ... if it's true.
However, Vanunu did not wait for the court's ruling: the London-based
Arabic newspaper Al Hayat published an interview with him Sunday,
which would constitute a violation of these restrictions.
Since his release from prison, Vanunu has been forbidden to talk to
the foreign press or maintain any contact with foreigners; to travel
abroad; to change his address without giving the security services 48
hours notice; or to leave town without giving them 24 hours notice,
among other restrictions.
His petition argued that these restrictions unreasonably infringe on
his basic human rights, and that there is no security consideration
to justify them because he has already told the world everything he
knows about Israel's nuclear program. The state argued that the
restrictions are necessary because he still has important information
that he has indicated he would reveal if given the chance.
In the Al Hayat interview, Vanunu charged that the Dimona nuclear
reactor endangers lives throughout the Middle East, because a strong
earthquake in the region could crack the reactor and cause
radioactive leakage that would result in the death of millions.
He also told the paper that the Jordanian government should start
preparing for possible leaks from the reactor, just as Israel
recently decided to distribute anti-radiation iodine pills to people
who live near the Dimona reactor.
He said that Jordanians
living close to the border with Israel should be tested for radiation exposure,
claiming that the Hashemite Kingdom
is particularly at risk from the reactor because it operates mainly
when "the wind blows toward Jordan."
Vanunu said that he does
not believe that the United States or European nations will press Israel
to reveal the full extent of its
nuclear capabilities. He also blasted Mohamed ElBaradei, head of the
International Atomic Energy Agency, for visiting Israel earlier this
month and not putting any pressure on Israel to open its nuclear
program to international inspection. "He should have done here what
he did in Iraq," the paper quoted him as saying.
Vanunu went on to say that he told the Sunday Times all
he knew about Israel's nuclear program, and that the information he had "was
enough to conclude that Israel presents a real danger to the entire Middle
East."
Vanunu also said he believes Israel has managed to build up its
nuclear arsenal during the years in which he was incarcerated.
Al Hayat said that this is the first interview Vanunu has given to a
newspaper since his release from an Israeli prison in April.
|